Fics like Gay Frat Monster Mash

A bunch of frat bros play a drinking game on Halloween. All of them turn you into a monster. At least one of them turns you gay.

You may also like

1. Clearing out the Shelves (Original Work)
2. Monster Handler by ThatSmutAccount (Original Work, No Fandom)
3. Cultural Collision by Udunie (Original Work)
4. Hollow Moon by Batzy (Original Work)
5. Digging Yourself Deeper by fullofshame (Original Work)
6. Winter's Warm Embrace by Diamond_Raven (Original Work)
7. A Faun's Harvest by DLManoir (Original Work)
8. Promises Made by plothound (Original Work)
9. Happy Trails by yumyumcereal (Original Work)
10. The Slime Tank by Goldenwarrior555 (Original Work)
11. Into the Deep by Bleeding_wing (Original Work)
12. simple (Original Work)
13. Smell like a man by AbberantDissent (Original Work)
14. Beg Borrow or Steal by turututuru (Original Work, No Fandom)
15. just this once (Original Work)
16. Tight Fit by RedSnowWhite (Original Work)
17. Irricine Online by 2ntwins (Original Work)
18. The Brotherhood of Bad Touch by MetaAllu, hellostarshine (Original Work, Furry (Fandom))
19. Unbound by RedSnowWhite (Original Work)
20. Treasured by Blue_GhostGhost, Delphyne (Original Work)