Fics like You could never have him from the start, Eric.

Eric doesn't know how to move on from Kyle after highschool, so he takes matters into his own hands. Which to him, of course means taking Kyle all for himself. Kyle wakes up in Cartman's basement instead of his dorm room. Conflicted and already struggling in his life, he has no idea what to do. They have no idea their feeling are mutual until much too late. This is a Kyle struggle fic pretty much 😭 I love all my babies in pain and I hope all of you do too!

You may also like

1. Craig has a camera. by orphan_account (South Park)
2. Through His Eyes by MookieSusu (South Park)
3. Dear Jewboy by why_didimakethis_account (South Park)
4. The Chat Room Scandal by 4orny (South Park)
5. Bigfoot? In South Park?? (More Likely than you Think) by GoblinintheGarden (South Park)
6. be still my (virtual) heart by mewtwos (South Park)
7. Keep Talking Shit Like That by angel555angel555 (South Park)
8. Footage by Yukitophantom (South Park)
9. I might let you make me Juno! by thegraveyardmortician (South Park)
10. Ladies and Gentlemen We Are Floating in Space by gremlinteeth (South Park)
11. Room No. 9 by alanciel (South Park, Room No. 9 (Visual Novel))
12. Cartman’s Little Red Book by Sinshipsahoy (South Park)
13. Ship In A Bottle by FayOfTheForest (South Park)
14. It's basically a weird cat, right? by verimakea (South Park)
15. The Violin by LucidDream21 (South Park)
16. Safety Net by metaljellyfish (South Park)
17. Prescription by orangecat12345 (South Park)
18. Scylla and Charybdis by Rainbow_Convection (South Park)
19. The Roommate by theyregonnagetme (South Park)
20. The Thief by Wintergrew (South Park, South Park: The Stick of Truth - Fandom)