Fics like Stay With Me

Jackie goes out riding on the horse Cole gifted to her. Something happens and she gets thrown off. The horse runs and Cole is the one to find her. Read to find out more.

You may also like

1. Enough to make you wonder... by The_1GurlwhoDontSlzzp626 (My Life with the Walter Boys (TV))
2. Your Freckles Lead the Way by IamJustLadyD (My Life with the Walter Boys (TV))
3. An Interrupted Cadence (My Life with the Walter Boys (TV))
4. I see you by Kissmeunderthemoonlight (My Life with the Walter Boys (TV), Walter boys - Fandom)
5. The One Ring to Tie Us Both by IamJustLadyD (My Life with the Walter Boys (TV))
6. One more Walter? by PotatoShapedBlob (My Life with the Walter Boys (TV))
7. Broken Bonds, Mended Hearts by teaoverpatriarchy (My Life with the Walter Boys (TV))
8. Fortunate Misfortune by myvalentyne (My Life with the Walter Boys (TV), Cole Walter - Fandom)
9. all i want is her by raynanisbett (My Life with the Walter Boys (TV))
10. Cole and Jackie Oneshots by VanillaAshes (My Life with the Walter Boys (TV))
11. Spectacular | My life with the Walter Boys by Aesthetic_rxssxs (My Life with the Walter Boys (TV))
12. Get me with those Green eyes by juicy_watermelonnnnnn (My Life with the Walter Boys (TV))
13. the prodigal black heir by colewalter (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them (Movies), more)
14. The Biggest Lie by zella026 (My Life with the Walter Boys (TV))
15. I Can't Stay Away from You by Dreamcatchergirl6 (My Life with the Walter Boys (TV))
16. could we be something? by sketchingasunburstsky (My Life with the Walter Boys (TV))
17. I'm always, forever, runnin' back to you by SpiderLeah (My Life with the Walter Boys (TV))
18. New York, I Need You by teacupstorm30 (My Life with the Walter Boys (TV))
19. The things we never said by Giuliab86 (My Life with the Walter Boys (TV))
20. Netflix original shows short prompts by Samjr04 (On My Block (TV), Bridgerton (TV), more)