Fics like Puzzle of Dreams

Bound to fight against each other with magic as their weapon and tents in a circus as their battleground, Gabriel and Sam were never supposed to use their weapons to woo each other. In which Sam and Gabriel toe the line between competitor and lover in a war to the death.

You may also like

1. Be Sure to Check the Price Tag Before You Accept an Offering by ScrollingKingfisher (Supernatural)
2. Don't Tell Dad (My Boyfriend Carries a Flaming Sword) by astrild (Supernatural)
3. Hark, the Herald Angel Sings by ScrollingKingfisher (Supernatural)
4. Side Effect by Janice_Lester (Supernatural)
5. To sleep, perchance to dream by Majinie (Supernatural)
6. A Matter of Trust by Elthadriel (Supernatural)
7. Perpendicular Lines by orphan_account (Supernatural)
8. Coffee and Tattoos by orphan_account (Supernatural)
9. Wings to Great Deeds by sithmarauder (Supernatural)
10. Time Again by JCapasso (Supernatural)
11. Just Go With It by consoul (Supernatural)
12. Halo by entanglednow (Supernatural)
13. 178 Rejections Later by StarlightDragon (Supernatural)
14. There For You by Aleatory (Supernatural)
15. The Slow Way by thirtyspells (Supernatural)
16. All I Want (is to solve your puzzle) by airspaniel (Supernatural)
17. Team Free Win by 74days (Supernatural)
18. And Stretch Your Wings Southward by Moorishflower (Supernatural)
19. The Milk and Honey Café by sanityisboring (Supernatural)
20. Cat Got Your Tongue? by Enmuse (Supernatural)