Fics like High Dive

Dean thought that maybe under the coy little smile of the local high school's swimming captain he'd find a stammering virgin. If only. [Cas is 17, Dean's in his early 20's]

You may also like

1. St. Mary's School for Boys by relucant (Supernatural)
2. Baby I Got Your Money by saltandbyrne (Supernatural)
3. The One With Dean's Anal Beads by triedunture (Supernatural)
4. We Are What You Say by artsyunderstudy (Supernatural)
5. The Great Outdoors by xylodemon (Supernatural)
6. This is Life that's so Thankless by Ste3o (Supernatural)
7. Whisper a Little by Sass_Master (Supernatural)
8. By The Horns by transdreamsicle (Supernatural)
9. Workplace Tension by thelonelywriter (Supernatural)
10. So Very by Sass_Master (Supernatural)
11. Good to be a Girl by Demon_Dark_Need (Supernatural)
12. Handmade by nealinor (Supernatural)
13. scarred heart in hand by perilously (Supernatural)
14. Wet by xylodemon (Supernatural)
15. no salvation here by xylodemon (Supernatural)
16. Get a Room by Mayalaen (Supernatural)
17. Black As Night by thraced (Supernatural)
18. Dean, I Need Your Help by fanfic814 (Supernatural)
19. A Graying Tower, Alone on the Sea by Annie%20D (Supernatural)
20. Bare Your Throat and Have Me by HigherMagic (Supernatural)