Fics like At her alter

Emily Prentiss, consumed by guilt and self-loathing, repeatedly seeks repentence in vampire!JJ, using their tumultuous relationship as a form of self-punishment while convincing herself it is penance rather than desire.

You may also like

1. Recognition by careful_abundance (Criminal Minds (US TV))
2. Drifter by 3v0l (Criminal Minds (US TV))
3. The Truth Told by Allie_04 (Criminal Minds (US TV))
4. Side Effects by maybemarky (Criminal Minds (US TV))
5. Surrender by rainybamboo (Criminal Minds (US TV))
6. Not Just Work Colleagues by SilkenObedience (Criminal Minds (US TV))
7. Are you jealous, JJ? by SwatKat_JJ_Emily (Criminal Minds (US TV))
8. The Art of Starting Over by baunitchief (Criminal Minds (US TV))
9. under the christmas tree by ohlittlebluebell (Criminal Minds (US TV))
10. two faced by herculexn (Criminal Minds (US TV))
11. death is promised to the bee by frankiebirds (Criminal Minds (US TV))
12. Undercover or Under Covers by nikonic (Criminal Minds (US TV))
13. Taking Turns by phoney823 (Criminal Minds (US TV))
14. This Mess We’re In by rabbitsheart (Criminal Minds (US TV))
15. Twin Flames by Tedwin (Criminal Minds (US TV))
16. Quarantini Group Chat by iwritesomestuffsometimes (Criminal Minds (US TV))
17. whatever she wants by plutosrobin (Criminal Minds (US TV))
18. headfirst, i dive, won't wait for time by jenhrding (Criminal Minds (US TV))
19. Professionalism In The Workplace by shipstershipsters (Criminal Minds (US TV))
20. it's getting harder to breathe by zashizawa (Criminal Minds (US TV))