Fics like The Strangest Strangers

The man was still for a while, watching Toby as if the boy were a wounded animal. This guy didn’t seem too dangerous, he was bigger than Toby, sure, but Toby was a fast runner. The ugly side burns also didn’t necessarily scream “danger” all that much, either. The boy narrowed his eyes at the man, his hand tightening around a hatchet, and eyebrows furrowing as he looked down at it. Why does he have this, and is this blood that it’s covered in? There was another one on the ground next to him too. He didn’t even realize he was carrying these. The man’s gaze followed Toby’s, and quickly raised his hands in mock surrender, stepping out from behind the tree. “What the hell happened to you, kid?” -- Or, my own take on how Toby met Tim and Brian.

You may also like

  1. Baby, Just Say Yes (Jeff the Killer x Reader) by ikearano (Creepypasta - Fandom)
  2. In Loco Parentis by Nymm_at_Night (Marble Hornets, Creepypasta - Fandom)
  3. The Places You Shouldn't Be (Creepypasta Oneshots) by WhaleTales1920 (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets)
  4. Seven Minutes in Heaven by rainrot4me (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets)
  5. Nailbed by faedemon (Marble Hornets)
  6. Moon's Hollow, Keep Howling by SyyntaxErrorr (Slender Man Mythos, Creepypasta - Fandom)
  7. Laughter Cures All by A2idB1u3 (Batman - All Media Types, DCU, more)
  8. Perfect Colorless Nothing - Creepypastas x Reader by Err404AuthorUnknown (Creepypasta - Fandom)
  9. hatchet by rottenstrawberrymilk (Creepypasta - Fandom)
  10. Regi's Creepypasta/MH Headcanons & Drabbles by regisvinex (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets, more)
  11. You'll Catch Your Death by Reabees (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets)
  12. Thinking VS Knowing. by Fanfiction_PACT (Creepypasta - Fandom, Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling)
  13. Home, Sweet Home (Creepypasta - Fandom, Slender Man Mythos)
  14. A new HAPPY Creepypasta life by kaykaye10 (Creepypasta - Fandom, Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling)
  15. Killer in the Mirror by gothicflowers (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Creepypasta - Fandom)
  16. What Hides in Shadows - A Worm Creepypasta by Beastrider9 (Parahumans Series - Wildbow, Creepypasta - Fandom, more)
  17. Collection of Headcanons & Drabbles (Various Creepypasta x F!Reader) by dirtyl0ver (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets)
  18. Spill Your Guts by Reabees (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets)
  19. Jeffrey Woods Adopts a Child by confusedmaniac (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Creepypasta - Fandom)
  20. It will come back by Kizuki_loves_u (Creepypasta - Fandom)