Fics like The Wreck of Our Hearts

Katherine Swann has spent years quietly, hopelessly in love with a man who only had eyes for her sister. When she follows Elizabeth to Tortuga, she is not prepared to find James Norrington—broken, lost, and entirely unaware that she has spent years loving him in secret. But love is not the same as being chosen—and some choices will break them both long before the Caribbean is done with them. When the Pearl sails, loyalties blur, and love becomes indistinguishable from betrayal. James Norrington x OC (Set during the events of Dead Man's Chest and will continue through At World's End and beyond.)

You may also like

  1. MHA: Alchemist Gamer by Darklord331, Light_He_arth (僕のヒーローアカデミア | Boku no Hero Academia | My Hero Academia (Anime & Manga), Doom (Video Games), more)
  2. Persephone by waterbird13 (Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies))
  3. Mediations by rat_posting (Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies))
  4. Catch the Wind by eriathiel (Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies))
  5. in this world or the one below by HopeStoryteller (Assassin's Creed - All Media Types, Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies))
  6. Little Sparrow by YunaYamiMouto (Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies))
  7. In Tortuga by IBegToDreamAndDiffer (Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies))
  8. Ye be Warned by TheDeadGirlRisen (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies))
  9. The Lord Who Learned to Love the Sea by FemaleOfTheSpecies (Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies))
  10. Wind in the Sails by themanypagesofhannah (Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies))
  11. Fathoms Below by Emeritus2386 (Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies))
  12. When I Let The Water Take Me by Clearpurpleskies (Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies))
  13. The Graveyard of the unfinished stories, AKA Roller coaster -rides in the land of fluff, first meetings and romance (see summary) by VenlaMatleena (The Lord of the Rings (Movies), The Hobbit (Jackson Movies), more)
  14. Like the Tides by MistressCryptid (Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies))
  15. With Strength Unbending by Born2Write (Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies))
  16. Until The Last Tide by Mermaidhair91 (Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies))
  17. Going Price by Arsenic (Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies))
  18. Introduction to Reality by Cleo_Calliope (Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies))
  19. Where, When, Why, Who & Howl by KateKintail (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Doctor Who (2005), more)
  20. To Court a Monster: Pirates of the Caribbean Edition by Rhiw (Pirates of the Caribbean (Movies))