Fics like And If You’ll Let Me

Toby comes face to face with…something. Something tall and grey and hulking, a deep gash leaking inky black liquid where Toby slashed it. It’s human but not, something with gaping black holes where eyes should be; a familiar shape warped in just enough ways to give Toby pause. To make Toby question. Aka Toby and Jack’s first meeting + how Jack ended up at the mansion. Short and sweet just for you.<3

You may also like

It will come back by Kizuki_loves_u (Creepypasta - Fandom)
In Loco Parentis by Nymm_at_Night (Marble Hornets, Creepypasta - Fandom)
After Party by meme_girlie (Creepypasta - Fandom)
Say my name instead by breathingstarsnotair (Creepypasta - Fandom)
Suffering Ends With Harry: A HEYS Rewrite by Foxflarechan (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Creepypasta - Fandom, more)
Spill Your Guts by Reabees (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets)
⨂rigin: The Man Who Wasn't There by InkHero (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets, more)
Everyday life by mysticalcreep (Creepypasta - Fandom)
Sit Down Beside Me by pantyhosepeepaw (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets)
Wind Around the Willow by Secret_Kitty (Creepypasta - Fandom)
Baby, Just Say Yes (Jeff the Killer x Reader) by ikearano (Creepypasta - Fandom)
Even A Worm Will Turn by starzkiss (Creepypasta - Fandom)
Can’t Help Falling in Love with You by Like_the_coldest_Winter_Chill (Creepypasta - Fandom)
Creepy Potter and the Order of Death by Piff (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Creepypasta - Fandom)
House of 1000 Corpses by Reabees (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets)
If you can't beat em', make em' bleed like pigs! by Cynical_Bunny (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets)
Breaking The Habit by Slythery (Danny Phantom, Creepypasta - Fandom)
Cleanse [eyeless jack] by alchemistic (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets)
Pyro Rogers by Smooth_brain_no_thoughts_head_empty (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Creepypasta - Fandom, more)
Thinking VS Knowing. by Fanfiction_PACT (Creepypasta - Fandom, Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling)