Fics like Milk Teeth

Toby was freshly sixteen and had been a proxy for about a year, and Tim had expected those circumstances to mellow his unofficial apprentice out. Proven wrong, he is sent to retrieve the problem child from a smoke sesh out by the lake with Jeff and Ben--bringing him back to his room to babysit him and find a way to get the jittery teen to calm the hell down.

You may also like

  1. A new HAPPY Creepypasta life by kaykaye10 (Creepypasta - Fandom, Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling)
  2. ⨂rigin: The Man Who Wasn't There by InkHero (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets, more)
  3. redacted title by orphan_account (SCP Foundation, Creepypasta - Fandom)
  4. Rain's Kinktober 2024 by rainrot4me (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets)
  5. Thinking VS Knowing. by Fanfiction_PACT (Creepypasta - Fandom, Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling)
  6. Duty of Care by OMINOUS_UNKNOWN_FREAK (Creepypasta - Fandom)
  7. Sit Down Beside Me by pantyhosepeepaw (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets)
  8. Toby X Masky X Hoody by Sinfullycreepy (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets)
  9. Harry Ends Your Suffering by Foxflarechan (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Creepypasta - Fandom, more)
  10. Home, Sweet Home (Creepypasta - Fandom, Slender Man Mythos)
  11. Chains: Eyeless Jack x Male Reader (NOT MY ORIGINAL STORY! READ SUMMARY!) by orphan_account (Creepypasta - Fandom)
  12. Numb Fingers by rainrot4me (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets)
  13. Unripe but Sweet by 13579 (Creepypasta - Fandom)
  14. The Dead Don’t Stay Buried | Various!Creepypasta x Reader by yuriversal (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets)
  15. If you can't beat em', make em' bleed like pigs! by Cynical_Bunny (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets)
  16. The Cabin in the Woods (Tim Wright/Masky x F!Reader x Brian Thomas/Hoodie) by dirtyl0ver (Marble Hornets, Creepypasta - Fandom)
  17. Twin Hatchets breaking down the Circus Tents by JESTER_DEMON (Creepypasta - Fandom, The Freak Circus (Visual Novel))
  18. In Loco Parentis by Nymm_at_Night (Marble Hornets, Creepypasta - Fandom)
  19. Deer Season (Tim Wright/Masky x F!Reader) by dirtyl0ver (Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets)
  20. Baby, Just Say Yes (Jeff the Killer x Reader) by ikearano (Creepypasta - Fandom)