Fics like The Tooth Fairy

Henry, a high school athlete, is taking care of his sister while his parents are out of town. After his sister loses her tooth, he sneaks into her room late at night to take it and leave money under her pillow. Right as he is entering her room, however, he finds the tooth fairy had already done his job for him. But the tooth fairy is not what Henry would have expected: he is an attractive teenage boy, and Henry quickly develops a little crush.

You may also like

1. Blood Legacy by TArtworks (Original Work, No Fandom)
2. Hail Mary: Grace by Inches by PL1 (Project Hail Mary - Andy Weir, Project Hail Mary (2026), more)
3. A Beginner's Guide to HTML and CSS on AO3 by the_untamed_poet25 (No Fandom, Fandom - Fandom, more)
4. A Complete Guide to 'Limited HTML' on AO3 by CodenameCarrot (No Fandom)
5. HTML/CSS Shenanigans by nerdzeword (No Fandom)
6. Chaotic Cultivation (Original Xianxia/Chaos Gacha) by Iceduke (Original Work, 幼女戦記 | Youjo Senki | Saga of Tanya the Evil (Anime), more)
7. Villainess From Hell [yandere demon harem x reader] by yona_yona (Original Work)
8. "Minuscule au sein des murs" (Tiny within the walls) by Cathiane (Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 (Video Game), The Borrowers Series - Mary Norton, more)
9. The Life and Times of a Worm by An_Fossorial_Rodent (Original Work, No Fandom)
10. The Intruder by dantesedmond (Original Work, No Fandom)
11. Infatuated by AnimaSola86 (Original Work, No Fandom)
12. Relentless Potential by CambrianBeckett (Original Work)
13. The Life and Tinies of Trevor by Zielregen (Original Work)
14. Daughter of the Rowan by LyraVex (Original Work, No Fandom)
15. Broken Pieces by devilskin (Original Work, No Fandom)
16. My son, the Honor Roll Hole by JDPM123 (No Fandom)
17. These Side Characters Have More Important Things To Do by bafflinghaze (Original Work)
18. Grievances to Grave by Azzandra, Whydah (Original Work)
19. Sky Is The Limit by Wolfox76 (Original Work)
20. A Barbaric Deal by 1_Angel_1 (Original Work, No Fandom)