Fics like Too Good To Be True

When Reid agreed to set up an online dating profile, he fully expected nothing to come of it. Then someone messaged him. And somehow, against every expectation, Reid found himself sitting on a park bench waiting for his first date. It should have been perfect.

You may also like

1. Lone Survivor by audioaujom (9-1-1 (TV), Criminal Minds (US TV))
2. Morning Disaster by soulmetalfairy (Criminal Minds (US TV))
3. Underground Parking by secondhandsorrow (Criminal Minds (US TV))
4. Hurt!SpencerReid Stories by loverofmanyfandoms19 (Criminal Minds (US TV))
5. Harbinger by Dark_Nymphs_translates (Supernatural (TV 2005), Criminal Minds (US TV))
6. merciful things by TrueLlama717 (Criminal Minds (US TV), Supernatural (TV 2005))
7. Revelations by The58thAcademic (Criminal Minds (US TV))
8. The Morning After by manwathiel_elensar (Criminal Minds (US TV))
9. He Was Left on the Steps of the FBI in a Basket by schrijverr (Criminal Minds (US TV))
10. There's nothing else I can do (But love you the best that I can) by IzzyMRDB (Criminal Minds (US TV))
11. For the World’s More Full of Weeping by IdLike2SayBeautifulThingsButIDontKnowHow (Criminal Minds (US TV))
12. I've Got You by The_Call_Of_Fantasy (Criminal Minds (US TV))
13. Fake Out by oldmannapping (Criminal Minds (US TV))
14. A Dusty Newsflash by AppalachianApologies (Criminal Minds (US TV))
15. A Spark by Kaatiba (Criminal Minds (US TV))
16. The BAU is No Place for a Bat by Rosie_the_Fanfic_Reader (Batman - All Media Types, Criminal Minds (US TV))
17. To profile a Chosen One (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Criminal Minds (US TV))
18. As The Gas Light Dims by writersagainstwritersblock (Leverage (US TV 2008), Criminal Minds (US TV))
19. Missing Piece by stridermagic (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Criminal Minds (US TV))
20. Dick Grayson: A Case Study by writersagainstwritersblock (Criminal Minds (US TV), Batman - All Media Types, more)