Fics like I Love You, But My Heart Belongs Here Now

Apparently II and BFDI Pencil are two different people (noooooooooooooo) But what if they weren't? What if a tiny loophole in the contract sent Pencil here? The society where they prioritize the things that BFDI is the exact opposite of? She'll have to learn, adapt, and most importantly, change for the better. Because in this world, order, safety, and cooperation are key. (In this AU Pencil does compete in II, and she's on Circumspect) Expect this work's writing to be subpar at best (get it? nevermind) (If details haven't been revealed yet, I will make some assumptions, if they are revealed later, I will NOT be changing the story)

You may also like

  1. I’ll Change For You by starry_leafy404 (Battle For Dream Island (Web Series))
  2. a girl through and through by Pikoloid39 (Battle For Dream Island (Web Series))
  3. I'd Have Two Nickels by Splotchy_Sneakers_417 (Battle For Dream Island (Web Series), Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  4. This is what makes us girls by hearts4remember (Battle For Dream Island (Web Series))
  5. But I'm a Cheerleader! by lilith_mt (Battle For Dream Island (Web Series), Inanimate Insanity (Web Series), more)
  6. Grey With Envy by sixsidedmisery (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  7. Sunsets and Scientists by RandmSillyX3 (Battle For Dream Island (Web Series))
  8. You're the one, You're all I ever wanted (I think I'll regret this) by rrainedrops (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  9. I don't even know bro by s1lly_fell0w (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  10. I Won't Move But I Can't Stay Here by NotYourProphet (Battle For Dream Island (Web Series))
  11. The Breaking and Fixing of Leafy by Secretarymany (Battle For Dream Island (Web Series))
  12. Planet Earth Is Blue (and There’s Nothing I Can Do) by Mayayu (Battle For Dream Island (Web Series))
  13. autism host house thing by Adioxazine (ONE - Cheesy Hfj (Web Series), It's Time For The (Web Series), more)
  14. Yaoi VS Yuri by GayChud1 (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series), Battle For Dream Island (Web Series), more)
  15. Hijacker by delihar, naoworshipper (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  16. Inanimate Insanity: Rewritten by wootzietoozee (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  17. Inanimate High by kinkaj0u (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  18. After It’s All Over (Battle For Dream Island (Web Series))
  19. Video Games | TrophySpoon Oneshot by NotSo_AnonymousBean (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  20. Broken Hearts Make It Rain by sunnibun (Battle For Dream Island (Web Series), X Finds Out His Value (Short Film 2008))