Fics like Instinct

Sam does his best to ignore the pull he feels towards the janitor at Crawford Hall; right up until he's holding a stake to his chest anyway.

You may also like

1. Time Again by JCapasso (Supernatural)
2. Five Times Sam Gave Gabriel the Kiss of Death (and One Time he Didn't) by ScrollingKingfisher (Supernatural)
3. Start Quoting Shakespeare and We're Done by pyrebi (Supernatural)
4. A Wrinkle in Time by JCapasso (Supernatural)
5. Your Bottle Is Empty (But Your Glass Has Been Filled) by jjtaylor (Supernatural)
6. Winter Walk by RosaleenBan (Supernatural)
7. All is Calm and All is Bright by Aleatory (Supernatural)
8. Out of Wilting Petals, Love Blooms by wolfish_willow (Supernatural)
9. Different Does Not Mean Broken by Aria_Lerendeair (Supernatural)
10. Fenrir by Sereno_Nocturne (Supernatural)
11. 178 Rejections Later by StarlightDragon (Supernatural)
12. Be Sure to Check the Price Tag Before You Accept an Offering by ScrollingKingfisher (Supernatural)
13. Stitched Up by ScrollingKingfisher (Supernatural)
14. Archangelica by nommunication (Supernatural)
15. Loyal by JCapasso (Supernatural)
16. Making Space by ScrollingKingfisher (Supernatural)
17. Rising Son by demonsboyking (Supernatural)
18. Kiss Me Like You Mean It by GreyMichaela (Supernatural)
19. Be My Guest by aLoggedInReader (Supernatural)
20. Found a Martyr in My Bed Tonight by Perpetual%20Motion (Supernatural)