Fics like A Bet's a Bet

When Sam bets Dean that he wouldn't be able to go through with getting a genital piercing, Dean is determined to prove him wrong. He feels pretty confident (or at least he's telling himself that), up until the moment he realizes that the piercer who will be handling (and stabbing) his dick is insanely hot.

You may also like

1. I Got Issues by Chrisinele_hime (Supernatural)
2. Astroglide Ships It by DaydreamSea (Supernatural)
3. Show-off by haikuhamster (Supernatural)
4. Best Laid Plans by Persephoneshadow (Supernatural)
5. I Put A Spell On You by Persephoneshadow (Supernatural)
6. Dean and the Feather by VersaceThong (Supernatural)
7. Ascension by DaydreamSea (Supernatural)
8. High Rise / Hard Fall by Castiel_Left_His_Mark_On_Me (Supernatural)
9. Starving Faithful by anothersea (Supernatural)
10. I Leave in My Heart by FagurFiskur (Supernatural)
11. Tongue in Cheek by IceFemme (Supernatural)
12. Take Me Away To Paradise by orphan_account (Supernatural)
13. Earn Your Stripes by PaperAnn (Supernatural)
14. When Porn Bloggers Collide by assbuttintheimpala (Supernatural)
15. Dominance by fanfic814 (Supernatural)
16. The Kinks by ashandcas (Supernatural)
17. Teenage Dirtbag by tsundeanre (Supernatural)
18. Aesthetics in Autoerotica by relucant (Supernatural)
19. I'll Be Good by NavajoLovesDestiel (Supernatural)
20. Dean and Castiel's Lagoon of Love by almaasi (Supernatural)