Fics like Glory in the Water

After the mysterious drowning deaths of three teens, Sam and Dean find themselves in a small town, investigating the possibility of a monster living in the local lake. Eventually, their search leads them to believe they're dealing with some kind of tentacle monster. They attempt to take down the creature, but it overpowers them, dragging Dean down into the lake. Sam, distraught, believes his brother is dead, but Dean awakens in a cave under the lake, being cared for by one of the monsters, Castiel. Even as Sam vows revenge, Dean finds himself falling for the strange creature who believes Dean is his mate.

You may also like

1. Loved You For A Thousand Years by NavajoLovesDestiel (Supernatural)
2. Human Things by HigherMagic (Supernatural)
3. Through the Looking Glass by JhanaMay (Supernatural)
4. Sam Accidentally Sees the Whole Picture by almaasi (Supernatural)
5. Battle Scars by RipUpTheEnding (Supernatural)
6. blooming stars by casbean (Supernatural)
7. The Tunnel of Love by xylodemon (Supernatural)
8. Angel Problems by fanfic814 (Supernatural)
9. Waiting for More by perilously (Supernatural)
10. we shovel all the ashes out by xylodemon (Supernatural)
11. We'll pretend until we won't by flyingsolo_flyingfree (Supernatural)
12. A hunter and his angel by schrijverr (Supernatural)
13. The Weight of Your Crimes by perilously (Supernatural)
14. Sweet Home by xylodemon (Supernatural)
15. Who's Counting? by Annie%20D (Supernatural)
16. Delilah by nephilisms (Supernatural)
17. The Mantra by hautesauce (Supernatural)
18. Unconditionally Horny and Eternally Sad by wormstaches (Supernatural)
19. The Gatlinburg Murders by ratherbehere (Supernatural)
20. The Occasional Sentimentality by Annie%20D (Supernatural)