Fics like Holy Fire

"Who are you?" says Castiel quietly. She blinks and her eyes click beetle-black. "My name is Set." When Castiel is captured by a mysterious demon with aspirations to the throne, the Winchesters—all three of them—have to work together to save him. Takes place after the end of season 11. Canon-compliant up through the season 11 finale; slightly divergent from the season 12 trailer.

You may also like

1. The Pull of Us by Shelikestv (Supernatural)
2. Keep Calm and Hold On by Aini_NuFire (Supernatural)
3. Falling Home by sunshinewinchesters (Supernatural)
4. The Choices We Make, The Roads We Take by super_skam310 (Supernatural)
5. The Proper Reunion by Name_Pending (Supernatural)
6. A Little Comfort Never Hurt by sassycashley (Supernatural)
7. Fragile and Composed by cgf_kat (Supernatural)
8. broken when I'm lonesome by SailorChibi (Supernatural)
9. a sip of home truth by bubblewrapstargirl (Supernatural)
10. Desiderium by gillasue345 (Supernatural)
11. How Dean and Castiel Got Fake Married by allthebeautifulthings9828 (Supernatural)
12. When You Call by 29Pieces (Supernatural)
13. Haven by inkandpaperqwerty (Supernatural)
14. In A Little While I'll Still Be Here Without You by imherecauseimnotallthere98 (Supernatural)
15. Please Don't Leave Me by jazmine8448 (Supernatural)
16. Living In Darkness by ipfreeely (Supernatural)
17. Scars by allthebeautifulthings9828 (Supernatural)
18. Whatever It Takes by cenotaphy (Supernatural)
19. Lost in Time by drmcbones (Supernatural)
20. No Poison in my Bones by sunshinewinchesters (Supernatural)