Fics like Anyone But You

OJ and some friends go to a haunted house together and prays that he won’t be stuck with Paper- the only person he cares about impressing- but of course, the gods ignore his prayers.

You may also like

  1. Five Times Taco Is Hungry, and One Time She's Full by LuminadeTea (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  2. Inanimate High by kinkaj0u (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  3. UNDO UNDO by thoopsy (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  4. Romance Target - A Payjay Fanfic by SillyBillyJayy (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  5. Chionophobia by LuminadeTea (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  6. Roommates-A Trife Fic by Acer_00 (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  7. Taking Care of You by Connor_Plant (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  8. Room 43// An Inanimate Insanity College AU by orphan_account (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  9. Burnt Out Lights by YearbookFanC2Bc (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  10. Entangled by venusjustnow (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  11. I don’t know if I can ever see you again. by SillyS0rrow (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  12. Second Chance from the Ashes by MochaMazing (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  13. Room for one more. A PayJay family fanfic by Kaizo_the_Bug (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  14. Spark of Hope by TallLiar (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  15. Settle by onetpot (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  16. Monarch Butterflies by PenandYinyangsno1point1fannn (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  17. Pick a rose, get the thorns by Spr0cketz (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  18. Recovery Days by KittYDoesItAO3Edition (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  19. ༺ღ༒Angels have brown hair༒ღ༻ by Tac_Nyan (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series))
  20. Yaoi VS Yuri by GayChud1 (Inanimate Insanity (Web Series), Battle For Dream Island (Web Series), more)