Fics like Polish My Nails

Dexter, even after everything his big brother had done, still believes he should have thought and talked things through once more before slicing his big brother's throat: he can't go back in time, so now he's stuck with the guilt of being the one to end the Moser family. At the anniversary of his brother's death, a visitor appeared, showing him a clue he never found during the game.

You may also like

1. cherry red by orphan_account (Dexter (TV))
2. born the same blood, you belong to me by atticuseros (Dexter (TV))
3. Gibson Girl. by ribcaq (Dexter (TV))
4. I'll Take You Away With Me by GhoulSanderson (Dexter (TV))
5. Can A Serial Killer Be Redeemed?(At All?) by Mewhenfrfr (Dexter (TV), Dexter Series - Jeff Lindsay)
6. The Red Means What The Fuck, Morgan by CarbohydrateCaretaker (Dexter (TV))
7. obsession by atticuseros (Dexter (TV), Obsession (Movie 2025))
8. Your place in the Garden of Holy Sins by Ms_Ballantrae_1709 (Dexter (TV))
9. Camellia Japonica by Vidria (Dexter (TV))
10. You Should Have Been Fired Nine Times Already by Winter_Writer (Dexter (TV), Criminal Minds (US TV))
11. A Dialogue. by ribcaq (Dexter (TV))
12. Seeing Red (And Maybe A Therapist) by TheKitten_Hoarder (Dexter (TV))
13. play things by orphan_account (Dexter (TV))
14. Die Well, For They Will Not Grieve by VTHX (Dexter (TV))
15. Nature & Nurture by MalloryB (Dexter (TV))
16. Black Dahlia by SpicyReyes (Dexter (TV))
17. Dexter Morgan: The Ultimate Pursuer — Season One by PillarsOfImpossibleHistory (Dexter (TV))
18. The Lies Between Us by petrichor_after_dark (Dexter (TV))
19. Unfiled by GimmeTheSadGayBoys (Dexter (TV), The Mentalist (TV 2008))
20. Dexter Morgan's Terrible, No Good, Very Bad Day (Until It's Not) by CarbohydrateCaretaker (Dexter (TV))