Fics like My Good Cop

Dexter and Keith go on a date that tries to be cute, but it turns dark fast.

You may also like

1. I want (your blood) by Abaddonn (Dexter (TV))
2. Darkly Dreaming of You by QueenEff (Dexter (TV), You (TV 2018), more)
3. Your place in the Garden of Holy Sins by Ms_Ballantrae_1709 (Dexter (TV))
4. Blood and Tells by GimmeTheSadGayBoys (Dexter (TV), The Mentalist (TV 2008))
5. Die Well, For They Will Not Grieve by VTHX (Dexter (TV))
6. Let Me (Get What I Want) by cloudsatall (Dexter (TV))
7. I'll Take You Away With Me by GhoulSanderson (Dexter (TV))
8. A Morbid Sense of Fun by scaryfangirl2001 (Dexter (TV), Six Feet Under)
9. Hide that memory deep in my mind again, where it should never have left. by charlottecandy (Dexter (TV))
10. No One Likes a Butcher by Ninjin_sensei (Dexter (TV))
11. Blood Red Key Lime Pie by petrichor_after_dark (Dexter (TV))
12. obsession by atticuseros (Dexter (TV), Obsession (Movie 2025))
13. A Reflection of Himself by digicha0s (Dexter (TV))
14. I-86 by Hunter797 (Dexter (TV))
15. you gave me my very first gun by scorpiod (Dexter (TV))
16. Marks Of The Evil One by Orent (Naruto (Anime & Manga), Dexter (TV))
17. Nature & Nurture by MalloryB (Dexter (TV))
18. blue velvet by atticuseros (Dexter (TV))
19. Blood Ties In Red by Booksby_Midnight (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Dexter (TV))
20. chronos nostos by atticuseros (Dexter (TV))