Fics like Secret Santa

S2. When Quinn Fabray draws Rachel Berry for Secret Santa, what starts as petty sabotage spirals into flirtatious gifts—proving holiday magic can thaw even the iciest rivalry. Written circa 2011-2018 and improved 2025.

You may also like

1. Thank You For Not Fucking My Boyfriend by too_true (Glee (TV 2009))
2. the first few hundred times by mostlyunstablefangirl (Glee (TV 2009))
3. nothing you confess (could make me love you less) by MaleficentsConscience (Glee (TV 2009))
4. Pushing It Down and Praying by futchfabray (Glee (TV 2009))
5. Cruel Intentions by makingmeblue (Glee (TV 2009))
6. Sharp notes and soft looks by faberry1uvrs (Glee (TV 2009))
7. The Secrets of the Ancestors by Fantastic_writer06 (Teen Wolf (TV), The Originals (TV), more)
8. viva la vida! by mistyintherivers (Glee (TV 2009))
9. you paint dreamscapes on the wall by mostlyunstablefangirl (Glee (TV 2009))
10. Teach Me to Fall by forgotmynameoh (Glee (TV 2009), Dancing with the Stars (US) RPF)
11. tell me something good (tell me, tell me, tell me) by sourpastels (Glee (TV 2009))
12. Something Special by rosenland (Glee (TV 2009))
13. how sue c's it by uniqueusernamegenerator (Yellowjackets (TV), Glee (TV 2009))
14. Time Takes Time by Celeste_F (Glee (TV 2009))
15. The Cheerleader by Komodo_Butterfly (Glee (TV 2009))
16. my heart is frozen still as i try to find the will to forget her somehow by phothisisnotit (Glee (TV 2009))
17. Something's Coming, Wild and Bright by elledelajoie (Glee (TV 2009))
18. But He'll Leave a Pretty Corpse by gleefulmusings (Glee (TV 2009))
19. Through Crooked Aim by heartsmadeofbooks (Glee (TV 2009))
20. Until We Burn Out by lusthurts (Glee (TV 2009))