Fics like Guilty As Sin?

Ending up in a rural town in upstate New York was never a dream of yours, nor was your ex-boyfriend who you're very much still in love with becoming a priest and ending up in the same rural town.

You may also like

  1. god, how i love you by ephemeralfragments (Knives Out (Movies), Wake Up Dead Man (2025))
  2. Arrivederci, Roma by swissarmymanenjoyer (Knives Out (Movies))
  3. John 8:32 (Knives Out (Movies))
  4. damascus, absolution, and star wars by i_regret_thatpersonalityquiz (Knives Out (Movies), Wake Up Dead Man (2025))
  5. Collateral Damage by that_one_kid (Knives Out (Movies))
  6. Abide With Me by itselwoody (Knives Out (Movies))
  7. Birds of a Feather by Dragonsandducks (Glass Onion (2022), Knives Out (Movies))
  8. suspicions by lxvenderjewel (Knives Out (Movies))
  9. take me the long way home by wickedvoid (Knives Out (Movies), Wake Up Dead Man (2025))
  10. Sweet and Heady by amor_et_mors (Knives Out (Movies))
  11. lavender haze by Levanswrites (Knives Out (Movies))
  12. Benoit Blanc and the Star of Bethlehem by Buttons_Buttons (Knives Out (Movies))
  13. Just Desserts by Starklyjd (Knives Out (Movies))
  14. Matthew 6:34 by itselwoody (Knives Out (Movies))
  15. Beneath the surface by motionsensorsun (Knives Out (Movies))
  16. A Foolish Act of Grace by that_one_kid (Knives Out (Movies))
  17. i don't remember (much) what he had to say by Arokel (Knives Out (Movies))
  18. 𝔊𝔬𝔳𝔢𝔯𝔫𝔬𝔯 𝔇𝔢𝔅𝔢𝔩𝔩𝔞'𝔰 𝔓𝔲𝔯𝔤𝔢 by witchwolfwriter (Knives Out (Movies), Glass Onion Knives out, more)
  19. the absence of the body, an abyss by Princex_N (Knives Out (Movies))
  20. Every Glove That Laid Him Down by CheersLads11 (Knives Out (Movies))