Fics like Build Me Up Buttercup

New York, 1973. Tyler Joseph works on Wall Street, Josh Dun is a music writer for theater. When they find each other once again Tyler's feelings shred the life he has built on denial; he fights against the guilt, the expectations, the world insisting their love is wrong, and the part of him that still aches for Josh. Even terrified, Tyler can’t stop reaching back for what they once had, but every time he gets close, Josh pulls him in only to push him away. Now, Tyler has to decide how much of himself he’s willing to change to win back a man who might never be his. TW: It's the 70s, so it's hard BUT I promise you they have a happy ending :)

You may also like

  1. (Don't) Leave Me Alone by Arachna (Twenty One Pilots, Clancy - Twenty One Pilots (Album))
  2. A mask that will alter his face. by Bones24 (Twenty One Pilots)
  3. Do Everything Now. by homeissbeliever (Twenty One Pilots, Tyler Joseph - Fandom, more)
  4. Let's Recelebrate (a Joshler story) by InthenameofJoshDun (Twenty One Pilots)
  5. one time for the saints and the sinners by reverseblackholeofwords (Twenty One Pilots, Clancy - Twenty One Pilots (Album))
  6. Who Feeds On Pain (Twenty One Pilots, Trench - Twenty One Pilots (Album), more)
  7. start fresh (next semester) by spookyjwd, tyjoxanax (Twenty One Pilots)
  8. My terrible alpha boss turned out to be an omega?! by kittami, pantal00n (Twenty One Pilots)
  9. Would you please hurry? by ibelieveinjoshler (Twenty One Pilots, joshler - Fandom)
  10. Getaway Car by LavishTylerJ (Twenty One Pilots, Tyler Joseph - Fandom, more)
  11. Luckily, I can read your mind. by homeissbeliever (Twenty One Pilots, Tyler Joseph - Fandom, more)
  12. C H O K E R by OptionalBlue (Twenty One Pilots (Band), Trench - Twenty One Pilots (Album), more)
  13. Point of No Return by twistyler (Tyler Joseph - Fandom, joshler - Fandom, more)
  14. When All the Darkness Fades Away by HammCheddr (Twenty One Pilots)
  15. Trying to Hold Onto You by Booksnstuff (Twenty One Pilots)
  16. Close Enough to Bruise by silvernhills (Twenty One Pilots)
  17. 500 Baskets by emeraldcitydowntowngirl (Bandom, Twenty One Pilots, more)
  18. Inside the Glass (Twenty One Pilots, Trench - Twenty One Pilots (Album), more)
  19. Amber Waves by puppygirl67 (Twenty One Pilots)
  20. Melancholic Temperament by CraveTheTop (Twenty One Pilots)