Fics like Good Boy, Caden in the Obsidian Cellar

Straight star athlete Caden thought he was untouchable. Down in the Obsidian Cellar, three men teach him otherwise.

You may also like

1. Straight Jock Miles Hypnotized by Step-Dad by jocktamer (Original Work)
2. Hard Knocks by devilskin (Original Work, No Fandom)
3. Magical Fleshlight by RedSnowWhite (Original Work)
4. Perfect Fit by GreyWayfarer (Original Work)
5. Turning the Tables by rebooting (Original Work)
6. Andy's Stolen Innocence by jocktamer (Original Work)
7. Rush Hour by copperandbones (Original Work)
8. Falling into Routine (Original Work)
9. Under the Dragon's Claw by gixi_ninja (Original Work)
10. sturm und drang by spit_kitten (Original Work)
11. How To Endure The Earth by empty_room (Original Work)
12. I Can Make You So Happy by malfailure (Original Work)
13. Daddy's best baby girl by yeahokaymaybe (Original Work)
14. Reprogramming by RareReputation (Original Work)
15. Love Thy Neighbor by Olento (Original Work)
16. Straight Connor, the Bodega Cumdump by jocktamer (Original Work)
17. Sinful Desires by MadraMorell (Original Work)
18. Camping (Original Work)
19. Accidentally Stuck in an MMORPG Sex Game by RedSnowWhite (Original Work, Dungeon Crawler Carl Series - Matt Dinniman)
20. Under the Skin by soljet (Original Work)