Fics like Sugar Cookies

When an unfortunate mugging leaves Pest in the care of the most annoying person in the world, he’s forced to spend the day at Party Noob’s house. An unexpected confession leads Pest to make a decision he immediately regrets. Surely just the result of a concussion, right?

You may also like

  1. afterglow by evilmafuyu666 (Regretevator (Roblox))
  2. The Illusion of Achievement by StimmyStim (Regretevator (Roblox))
  3. This Is Not a Sleepover by tisquel (Regretevator (Roblox))
  4. Carry You Home by Pestorino (Regretevator (Roblox))
  5. The Status Quo by tisquel (Regretevator (Roblox))
  6. Maybe This Time by duckyapple (Regretevator (Roblox))
  7. Unconditional Love (And Way Too Many Blankets) by Mudk1p (Regretevator (Roblox))
  8. Happy Birthday, Pest by tisquel (Regretevator (Roblox))
  9. Nightmarish Influence by CyberFiction (Regretevator (Roblox))
  10. 360° by Rita242008 (Regretevator (Roblox))
  11. Late Nights and Such by rayfalling (Regretevator (Roblox), Roblox (Video Game))
  12. Drink Responsibly by Gesuto (Regretevator (Roblox))
  13. concrete slabs and wooden carving by acutiatr (Roblox (Video Game), Regretevator (Roblox))
  14. Like Horns To Heaven by tomcatdisp (Regretevator (Roblox))
  15. Sleepover (Undergoing a rewrite) by NewsReporter (Regretevator (Roblox))
  16. First You, Then Me by Numbness (Regretevator (Roblox), Roblox (Video Game))
  17. PEST WINS BY DOING NOTHING by Barrytc (Regretevator (Roblox))
  18. One More Chance? by rockin_rockinator (Regretevator (Roblox))
  19. stars in the sky by saw_donic (Regretevator (Roblox))
  20. Pest get's cockwarmed, that's it. by Dimigo (Regretevator (Roblox), Roblox (Video Game))