Fics like 1 Time Halloween Sucked (+3 Times It Didn't)

We all know Garrett doesn't do Halloween - for very good reasons. But I always hoped that his life with Hannah and the kids would help heal parts of him and that he and Halloween could come to a mutual understanding. So here are 4 Halloweens over the course of Garrett's post-college life: 1 trick and 3 treats.

You may also like

  1. Do It Because You Love It by peiceabread (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  2. a good time, not a long time by piglemousse (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  3. Girls Night by fantasywishes (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  4. Where the Cracks Let Light In by WriteMyAnchor (Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, Off Campus (TV 2026))
  5. Needed This by WriteMyAnchor (Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, Off Campus (TV 2026))
  6. The Lakehouse Summer by cinnabloom (Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, Briar U Series - Elle Kennedy, more)
  7. The Marriage Contract by TesaMadd (Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, Off-Campus (TV series))
  8. The Fate of Ophelia by TesaMadd (Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  9. I’ll build my world around you, I need you so by flissfloo (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, more)
  10. Two-Minute Minor by PrimaveraSarah (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  11. longer than we planned, better than we thought by piglemousse (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  12. Curl Theory by somewhereintheafterglow (Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, Off Campus (TV 2026))
  13. Family Meetings by bottomlessnonsense (Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, Off Campus (TV 2026))
  14. Can I see you before the game? by Baylzebub (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  15. Bye Weeks and Biographies by ineverexpectedyou (Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  16. The only test I wanna ace is you by AmandaLovegood (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  17. devestatingly sinful. by Miss%20Singer (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  18. Post Faceoff Reimagined by PuckLuck28 (Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy, Off Campus (TV 2026))
  19. A Love Story of Epic Proportions by 447Forever (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)
  20. Falling Just As Hard by CiaraSky (Off Campus (TV 2026), Off-Campus Series - Elle Kennedy)