Fics like Better the Devil You Know

What if Jennifer hadn't accepted Needy's rejection after she'd told her what she was? What if she didn't give her a choice?

You may also like

1. Choke by Val_Creative (Jennifer's Body (2009))
2. A Teenage Girl's Guide To Not Being Possessed By A Demon by pirateygoodness (Jennifer's Body (2009))
3. Jennifer by phlesh (Jennifer's Body (2009))
4. Written in your blood by webofdreams89 (Jennifer's Body (2009))
5. You're Awful, I Love You by priestessamy (Jennifer's Body (2009))
6. Tumblr Drabbles by biscuitlevitation (Hannibal (TV), Carmilla (Web Series), more)
7. Horror Slashers x Reader Oneshots by MadBoffin (A Nightmare on Elm Street (Movies 1984-1994), Friday the 13th Series (Movies), more)
8. am I beautiful as I tear you to pieces? by yung_dawg_energy (Jennifer's Body (2009))
9. Sandbox Love Never Dies by shipmansjournal (Yellowjackets (TV), Jennifer's Body (2009))
10. Jennifer's Body: The Real Story by HappyPalmTree (Jennifer's Body (2009))
11. Shows [Reverse Harem x Reader] by Floatyflowers (Mean Girls (2004), Scream (Movies), more)
12. stop there, let me perfect it by deathsbinky (Jennifer's Body (2009))
13. Needy's Body by ShanaStoryteller (Jennifer's Body (2009))
14. She Walk Like A Zombie (Talk Too Cold) by Meduseld (Jennifer's Body (2009))
15. Sand box love (Jennifer's Body (2009))
16. she's mine by honestlydarkprincess (Jennifer's Body (2009))
17. honey, don’t feed me by lurkingspecter (Jennifer's Body (2009))
18. you're a parasitic, psycho, filthy creature finger-bangin' my heart by deathsbinky (Jennifer's Body (2009))
19. Jennifer's Corpse by Lullabyebye (Jennifer's Body (2009))
20. You Get Me Closer To God by scoopsofsun (Jennifer's Body (2009))