Fics like Fingerbib

A strange man (?) visits you every other night with great interest. You (begrudgingly) humor him.

You may also like

  1. Bait and switch (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  2. I’m Not Alone by Whimsicalwyvern (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  3. The Man That Comes At Night by Disco_Wizard01 (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  4. Desperation by ImTheColorQueen (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  5. No, I'm Not Ok (PaleGun) by Mooomz (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  6. Domesticating a Visitor by yinyangle (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  7. There, There, It’s Alright by Fishermenswarff (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  8. Late night visitor by CeruleanStarlight (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  9. You're Human Enough by Wingit666 (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  10. Teeth by WithoutTheTea (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  11. Come Outside (Fancomic) by placecebo (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  12. Untrust us (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  13. Not on his watch by Meerers25 (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  14. I’m Not a Man, You See, I Just Repeat by CloisterBlack (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  15. Homebody by Kawaiindigo (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  16. My Quiet Place to Rest by thfanficlover (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  17. Helping (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  18. Lick My Heart-- It Will Poison You by BallsInMyJaws4Ever (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  19. Pale Visitor x Reader | WARNING: If you see them do not engage! by PutiFlowy (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))
  20. What comes knocking by Puck536 (No I'm not a Human (Video Game))