Fics like 4. Alt 24. Winning a Teddy for the Other

Rory wins Ethan a big ole teddy bear during a fair game and Benny's a lil jealous

You may also like

1. Lucky Breaks by danielthegod (My Babysitter's A Vampire (TV 2011))
2. The Strings that Connect Us by heartienaps (My Babysitter's A Vampire (TV 2011))
3. Bound By Fate by bennyweirs_wife (My Babysitter's A Vampire (TV 2011))
4. Drown In My Love by urlocalbylershipper (My Babysitter's A Vampire (TV 2011))
5. My Babysitter's a Vampire: Season Three by bennyweirs_wife (My Babysitter's A Vampire (TV 2011))
6. Prompt Advent Calender 2025 by cosmicsapphic (Stranger Things (TV 2016), My Babysitter's A Vampire (TV 2011), more)
7. You stole my heart, so I stole your body. by queerquokka (My Babysitter's A Vampire (TV 2011))
8. Tis the season by MarsInsane (My Babysitter's A Vampire (TV 2011))
9. Love Bites by Fake_Ruby (My Babysitter's A Vampire (TV 2011))
10. etharah 4 ever by heartz4fangz (My Babysitter's A Vampire (TV 2011))
11. Welcome Back Dusker by heartz4fangz (My Babysitter's A Vampire (TV 2011))
12. Puppy love by Cocacola_333 (My Babysitter's A Vampire (TV 2011))
13. precious bones, strawberry sundaes, and beauty in abstraction by PixiePaint (My Babysitter's A Vampire (TV 2011))
14. Yandere! 2000's Tv shows Oneshots/Imagines (Hannah Montana (TV), Good Luck Charlie, more)
15. Birthday By Your Side by omen_jen (My Babysitter's A Vampire (TV 2011))
16. While they were dating by MyosotisLeila (My Babysitter's A Vampire (TV 2011))
17. Multiversial Nerd Group by ChaoticAria3, Chaotic_Greek_Lover (Gravity Falls, 地縛少年花子くん | Jibaku Shounen Hanako-kun | Toilet-bound Hanako-kun (Manga), more)
18. Fun Sexy Times 2 by MarsInsane (My Babysitter's A Vampire (TV 2011))