Fics like Are We Dating The Same Evan Buckley?

Buck accidentally goes viral in the local Facebook group Are We Dating the Same Person? after half his casual dates compare notes—deciding he must be a married cheater with a kid at home. Eddie finds the whole thing hilarious. Buck finds it mortifying.

You may also like

  1. [I do, I did, I will, I would] by paintyourwords (9-1-1 (TV))
  2. Gave me no messages, gave me no signs... by ReallySmartLadyMarieCurie (9-1-1 (TV))
  3. hey now, hey now by fallingthorns (9-1-1 (TV))
  4. Right Here Waiting (Come and Fall Into Me) by eightpackdiaz (9-1-1 (TV))
  5. this lovesick thing by fleetinghearts (9-1-1 (TV))
  6. SOS by paleredheadinascifi (9-1-1 (TV))
  7. Tell Me A Story by Ellesworth86 (9-1-1 (TV))
  8. your touch brought forth an incandescent glow by eddiesdiaz (9-1-1 (TV))
  9. two truths, one lie by ColorMeParanoid (9-1-1 (TV))
  10. for the first time, I didn’t feel alone by youdrewstarsaroundmyscars118 (9-1-1 (TV))
  11. the watermark of your breath on the glass (as we watched the neon fish swim past) by buckmeetsboy (9-1-1 (TV))
  12. Christopher Diaz and the road trip revelation by paleredheadinascifi (9-1-1 (TV))
  13. drool and other confessions by paleredheadinascifi (9-1-1 (TV))
  14. Are You Forgetting Something? by user_1224 (9-1-1 (TV))
  15. Secret St Valentine by Thenarache (9-1-1 (TV))
  16. Firehose and the Dream Police by beetlesandstars (9-1-1 (TV))
  17. Once is a coincidence by forgetmenvts (9-1-1 (TV))
  18. Earth is a very small dot by paleredheadinascifi (9-1-1 (TV))
  19. Take Another Little Pizza My Heart by Phreakycat (9-1-1 (TV))
  20. I’ll always be a bridesmaid (and I’ll never take one home) by paleredheadinascifi (9-1-1 (TV))