Fics like Nyctophobia.

Lost deep in a seemingly never-ending cave system and fresh out of torches, Jesse can no longer hide her fear of the dark. A special request! One of my favorites so far, actually. Original fic post here.

You may also like

1. Sleepy sweethearts by halomoji (Minecraft Story Mode, MCSM)
2. An Unexpected Visit by Haste_V (Minecraft (Video Game), MCSM, more)
3. always crawling back by mymblesmumbles (Minecraft Story Mode, MCSM, more)
4. Monday Already? by Lunaraen (MCSM, Minecraft Story Mode)
5. musings of an ocelot with a silver tongue by cronche (MCSM)
6. Answers by Zonerz (MCSM, Minecraft (Video Game), more)
7. Recovery by EndenA (Minecraft (Video Game), Minecraft Story Mode)
8. He held her for what felt like decades. by halomoji (Minecraft Story Mode, MCSM)
9. Code Name: Connections by SkeeBallCatt22 (Hermitcraft SMP, Dream SMP, more)
10. It Will Get Better by CoastalCalamity (MCSM, Minecraft Story Mode, more)
11. Better Together by EndenA (Minecraft Story Mode)
12. Crawlout Through The Fallout by Aquaticnaho, SilverSilence14 (Minecraft (Video Game), MCSM, more)
13. Hybrid by ArizaLuca (Minecraft (Video Game), Minecraft: Story Mode - Fandom, more)
14. Dreaming of a tomorrow with you by NULL_PHillmAX (Minecraft: Story Mode (Video Game), Minecraft Story Mode)
15. Afraid of Losing You by dorkousmcsmstuff (Minecraft Story Mode, MCSM)
16. Three Words, Three Tries by Blaze22 (Minecraft (Video Game), MCSM, more)
17. Sailors Song, Siren's Lament by SilverSilence14 (Minecraft (Video Game), MCSM)
18. late nights, sweet dreams by americancrunchy (Minecraft (Video Game), MCSM)
19. Rebel of Sky City by shielddrake42 (Minecraft (Video Game), Minecraft Story Mode)
20. What You Were Before by Oofers (Minecraft (Video Game), Minecraft: Story Mode - Fandom, more)