Fics like Nobody New

You and Ethan are in the same friend group and you guys are all at a Halloween party. You and Ethan both talk for a bit before he walks you back to your dorm, in which you invite him inside since your roommate, Mindy, is staying with her girlfriend Anika for the night.

You may also like

1. stereotypical by MattUlrichSkeetLillard (Scream (Movies), Scream'd: An Unauthorized Musical Parody - Heard & Grayson)
2. savior complex by bloodhails (Scream (Movies))
3. Sensual Stalker by Scary_idiot_brainrot (Scream (Movies))
4. False Scare by GoWithTheFlo20 (Scream (Movies), Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling)
5. Horror Movie Headcanons by macabrebatz (House of Wax (2005), Hellraiser (Movies 1987-2018), more)
6. Tell Your Friends by Dinodesu (Scream (Movies))
7. Take My Breath by Dinodesu (Scream (Movies))
8. you're everything i want (plus everything i need) by biblio-smia (Scream (Movies))
9. Kidnapped by rainbowdaisy (Scream (Movies), Dead by Daylight (Video Game))
10. Horror Villains x Reader Smut Compilation by PastelPukePink (A Nightmare on Elm Street (2010), A Nightmare on Elm Street (Movies 1984-1994), more)
11. let me hear you scream by b0dacious (Scream (Movies))
12. Shake the Hand of the Devil by Hooked_on_a_Feeling (Dead by Daylight (Video Game), Scream (Movies))
13. What Are You Wearing? by siento (Scream (Movies))
14. Wax Melt - Slasher Soulmate Isekai AU by taylorbean (House of Wax (2005), Hannibal (TV), more)
15. he's a keeper, he's a believer by imsodirty_babe (Scream (Movies))
16. Debaser (But Billy is trans this time) by Sharpthing (Scream (Movies), scream - Fandom)
17. Unconditionally by DisastersAreAJoy (Scream (Movies))
18. love evolves into unknowns by pussyandautism (Scream (Movies), Scream 5 - Fandom)
19. my love for you is blood soaked by MattUlrichSkeetLillard (Scream (Movies), Scream'd: An Unauthorized Musical Parody - Heard & Grayson)
20. Day 14: I'll love you till the end of time by spicykoalabear (Scream (Movies))