Fics like Save a horse, ride a jock

After a drunken exploration of each other’s bodies came the vow of silence. At this point, Till was practically half a virgin. Half, not full, Ivan had told him when he convinced Till to do it in the ass. The pussy is off-limits, was his only rule. Some lines had been blurred along the way, he had to admit. Till agrees to a couple’s costume, not knowing it’s a trick. Unfortunately, he’s the one in the skimpy cowgirl outfit, not knowing it’s from Ivan.

You may also like

"brocon" is very fitting for you actually by devilmaid (Alien Stage (Web Series))
a slippery slope (insert some joke about lube (please laugh)) by quillifer, yamscooper (Alien Stage (Web Series))
he would never! (he totally would) by Ariariariadne (Alien Stage (Web Series))
a dog and a cat meet in... their bedroom?! by dirtmemer (Alien Stage (Web Series))
Consume Me by FallLover (Alien Stage (Web Series))
running is an endurance sport, did you know that? i don’t think you can outrun me, by the way by dirtmemer (Alien Stage (Web Series))
if you ever get desperate by moldystrawberries (Alien Stage (Web Series))
First live by akitsukun (Alien Stage (Web Series))
among the stars, with you by lunarias (Alien Stage (Web Series))
(please be s)till, my heart by moongallery (Alien Stage (Web Series))
OSTINATO by joukhr (Alien Stage (Web Series))
halo defect by babytill (Alien Stage (Web Series))
I grew a garden within the rot by Dawn_007 (Alien Stage (Web Series))
My Shining Star (Alien Stage (Web Series))
promise, baby, i'll take you to heaven (if you want it) by nochungguk (Alien Stage (Web Series))
No, this isn't a "Y/N" moment. by sybssite (Alien Stage (Web Series))
The Weight of Sin Upon Your Lips by Vykha (Alien Stage (Web Series))
Virgin emo twink gets pussy pounded by massive hung jock by aryu (Alien Stage (Web Series))
you look so pretty when you put me down by justiceforfreddie (Alien Stage (Web Series))
Lovestruck Paradox : Guide to Seduce your Enemy by Spicytunasandwich (Alien Stage (Web Series))