Fics like Better Than One

"I'm saying that it doesn't seem fair that Lucy only gets to have one kind of happiness when we know she deserves both." "You think we should... share," John says slowly. "Lucy. Us. As in, me and you, and her. That's not—Look, you're handsome and all, but I'm not interested in a threesome." Harry quirks a brow. "You think I'm handsome?" He can't help but tease. "Fuck off, you know what I meant," John says with a scowl. ---- Or the first in a series of one-shots exploring the polyamorous ending we all deserved from Materialists. Or or Harry solves everyone's problems for them by just wanting the people he cares about to be happy.

You may also like

Don't Let It End by Isabella2004 (Materialists (2025), The Materialists)
The Camgirl and the Millionaire by Kays_corner93 (Materialists (2025))
Close To You ❦ Harry Castillo by panakinthedisco (Materialists (2025))
Idealists (2025) by foxlorests (Materialists (2025))
Summer Affair by gothcsz (Materialists (2025))
strictly off the record by oceanofpascal (Materialists (2025))
Under the Right Conditions by BrabraYaga (Materialists (2025), Better Things (TV 2016))
Lemonade by JustAGalWhoWrites (Materialists (2025))
Kinktober 2026 by Paulyenvol6 (The Last of Us (TV), Narcos (TV), more)
Glitch by Mirrorbvall (Materialists (2025))
Hopelessly Devoted by Isabella2004 (Materialists (2025))
Make Him -Dislike- Love You by missadangel (The Materialist, The Materialists, more)
Ordinary Magic by Paradox_Rose (Defending Jacob (TV 2020), The Loss of a Teardrop Diamond (2008), more)
Falling Inn Love by lonely_ey3s (Materialists (2025))
Baby Contract by absurdthirst, storiesofthefandomlovers (Materialists (2025))
The Inevitable by reedispunk (Materialists (2025))
husband material by mcthsman (Materialists (2025))
vol. 2: now comes us by pedroscurls (Materialists (2025))
Stubborn Hearts & Coffee Debts by QueenOfSlowburn (Pedro Pascal - Fandom, The Last of Us (TV), more)
Everything I Know About Love by Mirrorbvall (Materialists (2025))