Fics like Stuck in the closet

Tiffany Falconer was seconds away from committing second-degree murder. Sure, she’d miss the prom. And graduation. And college. And probably the rest of her pre-planned life, because stabbing someone- even a Lori Granger someone- with a sequined heel in a janitor’s closet wasn’t exactly a misdemeanor.

You may also like

  1. I hope I was your favourite crime by fkevin073 (Fear Street Trilogy (TV), Fear Street Series - R. L. Stine)
  2. (there must be) a devil between us by sun_stardust (She-Ra and the Princesses of Power (2018), Fear Street Trilogy (Movies 2021))
  3. marked me like a bloodstain by fkevin073 (Fear Street Trilogy (TV), Fear Street Series - R. L. Stine)
  4. Percy’s Multiversal Conquests (Percy Jackson and the Olympians - Rick Riordan, Avatar: The Last Airbender (Cartoon 2005), more)
  5. A Goode Thanksgiving, Merry Christmas, and Happy New Year by annieoakley1 (Fear Street Trilogy (TV), Fear Street Series - R. L. Stine)
  6. Kinktober 24-25 by JerryHale (The Babysitter (Movies - McG), Slumber Party Massacre (Movies), more)
  7. Quid pro quo by Didnteatyet (Fear Street: Prom Queen (Movie 2025))
  8. raised to be in love - and they are by booooooarhch (Fear Street Series - R. L. Stine, Fear Street Trilogy (TV))
  9. right where you left me by fkevin073 (Fear Street Trilogy (TV), Fear Street Series - R. L. Stine)
  10. Summer Dawn Hotel by James_Stryker (iCarly, Victorious (TV), more)
  11. on this harvest moon by fkevin073 (Fear Street Trilogy (TV), Fear Street Series - R. L. Stine)
  12. everybody knows (that you're in love) by fkevin073 (Fear Street Trilogy (TV), Fear Street Series - R. L. Stine)
  13. ...so much so that it terrifies me. by lailaology (Fear Street: Prom Queen (Movie 2025), Fear Street Trilogy (Movies 2021), more)
  14. I'll win your love or I'll take the fall by annieoakley1 (Fear Street Trilogy (TV), Fear Street Series - R. L. Stine)
  15. (I Promised) And We Meet Again by Aesir_Wings (Fear Street Trilogy (TV), Fear Street Series - R. L. Stine)
  16. Puppy Love by orphan_account (Fear Street Trilogy (Movies 2021), Fear Street Series - R. L. Stine, more)
  17. Devil Inside by annieoakley1 (Fear Street Trilogy (TV), Fear Street Series - R. L. Stine)
  18. smells like teen spirit by fkevin073 (Fear Street Trilogy (TV), Fear Street Series - R. L. Stine)
  19. I loved in shades of wrong by fkevin073 (Fear Street Trilogy (TV), Fear Street Series - R. L. Stine)
  20. seasons change but we're still running in circles by fkevin073 (Fear Street Trilogy (TV), Fear Street Series - R. L. Stine)