Fics like Before It's Wrong (Markiplier x Reader)

You weren’t supposed to matter to him. Just a high school girl and her tutor—nothing more. But something unspoken began to bloom. And when the line between innocent and intimate started to blur, everything you thought you understood began to crack. The age gap made it wrong. The secrecy made it worse. What happens when you give someone your heart before you even know what love really is?

You may also like

  1. the softest echo (could be enough for me to make it through) by sunsetsundae (Project Hail Mary (2026), Iron Lung (2026))
  2. Within A Spectroscopic Binary by oofouchyikes (Iron Lung (2026), Project Hail Mary (2026))
  3. Something to Lose by S666t666n (Project Hail Mary (2026), Project Hail Mary - Andy Weir, more)
  4. Space is Vast, but Somehow We Found Our Way Home by BionicPocahontas (Project Hail Mary - Andy Weir, Project Hail Mary (2026), more)
  5. sternum a sternum by fourever_sk8r (Iron Lung (2026), Project Hail Mary (2026), more)
  6. Growing Pains by thatisnotokay (Iron Lung (2026), Andy Weir's Project Hail Mary - All Media Types)
  7. When It's A Fishbowl by chaya (Iron Lung (2026), Project Hail Mary (2026))
  8. Rootbound by tak_cajaz (Project Hail Mary (2026), Iron Lung (2026))
  9. Tired of Dead Cats by Katumi_art (Iron Lung (2026), Project Hail Mary (2026))
  10. Thrown Into The Loop by Womposaurus (In Space With Markiplier (Web Series), Iron Lung (2026))
  11. Bloody Rags by BlueGrassSax (Iron Lung (2026), Project Hail Mary (2026), more)
  12. Darn it, let’s do this one final time! by The_River_Girl (Project Hail Mary (2026), Spider-Man: Spider-Verse (Sony Animated Movies), more)
  13. Mary, Mary, Quite Contrary (Comic) by BronzePlates (Project Hail Mary (2026), Iron Lung (2026))
  14. where nothing bleeds by interstellarisms (Iron Lung (2026), Project Hail Mary (2026), more)
  15. What's with this sassy lost child? by Sniper_mask (Project Hail Mary (2026), Project Hail Mary - Andy Weir, more)
  16. Together at the Edge of Tomorrow by oopsididitagain404 (Project Hail Mary - Andy Weir, Project Hail Mary (2026), more)
  17. SloeBurn by thepossumwrites (Iron Lung (2026), Project Hail Mary (2026), more)
  18. Beneath a Crimson Surface by VikCacao (Project Hail Mary - Andy Weir, Project Hail Mary (2026), more)
  19. I Might Have [Loved You] by TwistyTrash (Iron Lung (2026), Andy Weir's Project Hail Mary - All Media Types, more)
  20. better not to breathe (than to breathe a lie) by CorpusChorus, PoemIsDead (Markiplier TV (Web Series), Jacksepticeye Power Hour (Web Series))