Fics like Choices, Choices, Choices

Five times Paul Baker manages to avoid making a decision, and the one time he makes the most important one (choosing Anton).

You may also like

1. breaking the spell by s0ld_it (Adults (TV 2025))
2. annulments by dejame (Adults (TV 2025))
3. brick by brick by wafflesofdoom (Adults (TV 2025))
4. fall into me and then... by blipbloop (Adults (TV 2025))
5. let me fall into your gravity by yaz113 (Adults (TV 2025))
6. abstinence is just a state of mind by rinpanna (Adults (TV 2025))
7. New relationship jitters. by HeatedRivalryIlya (Adults (TV 2025))
8. the cure by wafflesofdoom (Adults (TV 2025))
9. Two In Between Things (That Made Sense) by screamoffkey (Adults (TV 2025))
10. It's True, Man by ausfly (Adults (TV 2025))
11. Paul Baker Thinks Shane Hollander is ‘Nasty’ at Hockey by isto4u (Heated Rivalry (TV), Adults (TV 2025))
12. Spin the Bottle by isto4u (Adults (TV 2025), Game Changers | Heated Rivalry - All Media Types)
13. and i got a feeling wounds are healing by professional_girlkisser (Adults (TV 2025))
14. Put Your Lips on Mine and Shut Me Up by mi_mags (Adults (TV 2025))
15. strawberries and cigarettes by sadlyalex (Adults (TV 2025))
16. Spell Breaking by JaeBoo730 (Adults (TV 2025))
17. Paul Baker Has Gay Dads?! (9-1-1 (TV), Adults (TV 2025))
18. You're All That I Have, But Can't Get by infinitysynth (Adults (TV 2025))
19. Never Too Much by DragonBinx (Adults (TV 2025))
20. mindwipe (Adults (TV 2025))