Fics like Our Boy Tonight

“Did you ever sleep with Benny? Before we met?” The question caught Dean off guard. It certainly didn’t feel like an accusation, and in any case, Dean hadn’t, but it was such a random inquiry. He couldn’t figure out Cas’ sudden interest in the subject and his confusion had him floundering for a moment before he responded. “Naw Cas. I mean, he’s a good lookin’ guy, but we never hooked up.” That settled, Dean nuzzled his face into the pillow, intent on drifting off to sleep. It was not to be. It seemed Cas wasn’t done with him quite yet. “But you’ve thought about it.” Cas didn’t even make it a question, just a statement of fact, waiting to be confirmed by Dean’s reply.

You may also like

1. Like Catnip by KreweOfImp (Supernatural)
2. Boys On Film by LoversAntiquities (Supernatural)
3. The Scening Route to the Heart by MashiarasDream (Supernatural)
4. One Need in the Night by LoversAntiquities, relucant (Supernatural)
5. put color in your cheeks by CherryIce (Supernatural)
6. Sunday by LoversAntiquities (Supernatural)
7. Dirty by littleartemis (Supernatural)
8. Old Flames by thelonelywriter (Supernatural)
9. Shut Your Mouth by runoutofwit (Supernatural)
10. Cowboy's Sweetheart by prosopopeya (Supernatural)
11. It Started Innocently by Partyintheimpala (Supernatural)
12. Fuck for the World by sobsicles (Supernatural)
13. Repeatedly by casbean (Supernatural)
14. Fourscore by saltandbyrne (Supernatural)
15. Cuff Him by CBFirestarter (Supernatural)
16. Winter Games by KreweOfImp (Supernatural)
17. The Mob Boss's Submissive by LerDan (Supernatural)
18. Cats Cradle by NadiaHart (Supernatural)
19. Elevator Music by Ketch22 (Supernatural)
20. Sweetest Taboo by LoversAntiquities (Supernatural)