Fics like My Past Has Left its Mark

Matthew's pass comes to haunt him, but he doesn't want the others to know, they're finally on good terms, he can't let them see him at his worse.

You may also like

1. Feelings by Fresas_Bg (The Chosen (TV 2017))
2. (My Fingers are) Outta Place by Deedlejuice (The Chosen (TV 2017))
3. The Boiling Isles react to the human kingdom and the beings that inhabit that world. by ShadowKing1127 (The Owl House (Cartoon), DCU, more)
4. Principium by Jbart447 (The Chosen (TV 2017), Christian Bible (New Testament))
5. For My Brother by Just_A_Fangirl22 (The Chosen (TV 2017))
6. Reconciliation by Jbart447 (The Chosen (TV 2017))
7. Zonah Redeemed by TriceratopsWrites (The Chosen (TV 2017), Christian Bible (New Testament))
8. Adorable: A Study in Matthew by Deedlejuice (The Chosen (TV 2017))
9. The Days In-between by Just_A_Fangirl22 (The Chosen (TV 2017))
10. You're My First Friend by enchantedquill7 (The Chosen (TV 2017), Christian Bible (New Testament))
11. Trouble by Just_A_Fangirl22 (The Chosen (TV 2017))
12. The Parable of the Lost Brother by Deedlejuice (The Chosen (TV 2017))
13. Matthew centric one shots by NellieFant15 (The Chosen (TV 2017))
14. For All Have Sinned and Fallen Short by Psychodahlia (The Chosen (TV 2017))
15. "A Dumb Spirit" by Till_We_Have_Faces (The Chosen (TV 2017))
16. The Chosen: Stories Untold by Just_A_Fangirl22 (The Chosen (TV 2017))
17. Cares by Fresas_Bg (The Chosen (TV 2017))
18. All the Creatures of the Earth by Psychodahlia (The Chosen (TV 2017))
19. A Band of Apostles, a Rabbi, and a Storm Girl by Brokenfangirl22 (The Chosen (TV 2017), Christian Bible (New Testament))
20. Gentile. by The_Chosen_Fanfiction (The Chosen (TV 2017))