Fics like Ignorance is bliss (or maybe ignorance is bait)

They knew. These ancient Gods knew what she had done. They wanted something Holy, something that could not be undone in the eyes of the One True God. And there was one thing Holiest above all else, the reason Mary was chosen to carry Christ, and the thing Grace had vowed to save until she was safely married in the eyes of the Lord and the law. or, Grace loses her virginity and loses her shit Title from Heaven's Gate by Amélie Farren

You may also like

  1. I didn't mean to./But I want more. by CaseyDubo (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid, Nerdy Prudes Must Die - Fandom)
  2. what remains by Borashore (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid)
  3. a bad case of the butterflies by fruitopia (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid)
  4. Football (but for girls) by TheNarwhalGal (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid)
  5. Grace Chasity and the Sin of Existing by FlalaLadyGuggenheim (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid)
  6. God Loves You, But Not Enough to Save You by thephrogger (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid)
  7. Don’t Listen To Your Friends (See The Despair Behind Their Eyes) by The_lazy_eye (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid)
  8. Unpacking God in the Suburbs by The_lazy_eye (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid)
  9. you wouldn't like me, if you saw what was inside me by geicogecko (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid)
  10. Life Among the Nerdy Prudes by TheCrampReturns (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid)
  11. the goat by attentiondeficitdisaster (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid)
  12. Somewhere Else (In a tiny town called Hatchetfield) by orphan_account (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid, The Magnus Archives (Podcast))
  13. The Step By Step Guides by like_a_jock_he_cliches (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid)
  14. Dress Rehearsal by 578memorylane (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid)
  15. A Collection Of Final Words Before Death by like_a_jock_he_cliches (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid)
  16. The Blame Game by TheNarwhalGal (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid)
  17. Keep It Copacetic by imnotdyingbutyouallare (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid)
  18. Of Melodies and Martyrdom by RenReadsStuff (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid)
  19. Finding Home Again by AnotherPinkGhost (Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid)
  20. Her Grace by SaphDragon494 (Slay the Princess (Visual Novel), Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid)