Fics like Into Tartarus

For 10 years, the guilt ate away her soul. For 10 years, she was haunted by the actions of her past, until she had all but given up on living. Now she's back to the source of it all, seeking answers to the past, and punishment for her apathy all those years ago. Instead, she finds something else.

You may also like

1. Innovation Is Key (May We Forget Death) by calypso_willow (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
2. Cat Got Your Tongue? by MidnightMare247 (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
3. Birds of a Feather (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
4. Guardian Angel by Bunvunny (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
5. I Can Make It Better by Origingirl (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
6. The Angel of Playtime by TrionixPrimeSophia (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
7. Poppy Worldwide: SALVATION ROUTE by Mizpa (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
8. Poppy Worldwide: TRUE SALVATION ROUTE by Mizpa (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
9. Full House by DucksAreLife (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
10. Your Plastic Heart by Limbo_writes (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
11. A New Safe Haven (This Family Needs You) by fiber_optic_alligator (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
12. Love Him Till The Day That You Die! by wasthatafanfic (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
13. They Wait For You by RosesCry (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
14. Extra Hand You Can’t Refuse by Iceysnow (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
15. Butcher Me Next by thfanficlover (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
16. Beware of the cat by M00FF1NN (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
17. A guide on how to get rid of a pesky dog. (Spoiler, you can't.) by Imnotevenheresobye (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
18. Playtime's Angel by That_One_L0ser (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
19. Late Night Talks With Ollie (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))
20. What’s the Time? (Playtime) by SissiReads_Unicorn26 (Poppy Playtime (Video Game))