Fics like Atonement

Ethan comes back to Vanessa to face the consequences of rejecting her. Lots of angst and pain and anger and regret and love. Season 3 AU/redo.

You may also like

1. Not My First Rodeo by VelveteenThestral (Penny Dreadful (TV))
2. Eventually by Piggie50 (Penny Dreadful (TV))
3. The Innocent by germanjj (Penny Dreadful (TV))
4. Utmost Bliss by talaricula (Penny Dreadful (TV))
5. A Waste of Shame by FrostedFox (Penny Dreadful (TV))
6. A Better Predator by Spare_Sidekick (Penny Dreadful (TV))
7. Opium Dreams by VelveteenThestral (Penny Dreadful (TV))
8. This One Made A Pig Of Me by OerbaIzalith (Penny Dreadful (TV))
9. Do Not Go Gentle by icarus_chained (Penny Dreadful (TV))
10. Shooting Lesson by Ellimac (Penny Dreadful (TV))
11. The Space Between Two Bodies by Only_1_Truth (Penny Dreadful (TV))
12. Typecast by days4daisy (Penny Dreadful (TV))
13. A Matter of Life and Death by callay (Penny Dreadful (TV))
14. Underneath It All by Taste_of_Suburbia (Penny Dreadful (TV))
15. Under Stars and Wing by WitchWayWizardry (Justice League - All Media Types, Teen Titans - All Media Types, more)
16. On the Use of Intercourse as a Cure for Ennui by Fyliwion (Sherlock Holmes & Related Fandoms, Sherlock Holmes - Arthur Conan Doyle, more)
17. Fictional Milf Oneshots by lyssiesroses (Multi-Fandom, Marvel Cinematic Universe, more)
18. The Fool by days4daisy (Penny Dreadful (TV))
19. To What End by q79vx6pr10 (Penny Dreadful (TV))
20. The Man from Nowhere by orphan_account (Penny Dreadful (TV), Red Dead Redemption (Video Games), more)