Fics like Would You Rather? - With Your Lovely Host, Casita!

Casita-Never-Fell AU, where no one learned their lesson and Bruno never came back. The Madrigals are subjected to a game of ‘Would You Rather?’ by the Miracle as punishment for their failures over the years. Casita is the ‘friendly’ co-host. Based loosely on the terrible horror movie from 2012 Would You Rather? The Miracle is NOT kind to them. They haven’t learned their lessons here. Agustin, Felix, and Antonio get no real punishments. Antonio for obvious reasons. He’s her favorite. If anyone is bypassing this because of character death and Mirabel dies...let me say it's not permanent. I will not write Mirabel dies fics. Complete. Mini epilogue with Antonio exploring the dinosaurs and helping a very special blue raptor find her daddy.

You may also like

  1. When The Miracle Is Gone, All That Remains Are Curses by TerribadFixx (Encanto (2021))
  2. The Pact by Seraphim_Burning (Encanto (2021))
  3. It's My Problem, It's My Problem (If I Wanna Pack Up And Run Away) by sujebbibbi (Encanto (2021))
  4. Bruno's slow return to the Family by YuiUltima (Encanto (2021))
  5. Mirabel Madrigal One-Shots by Mirabelharem (Encanto (2021))
  6. I know Its You // Camilo x reader by ms_indiffwrent (Encanto (2021))
  7. Fresh Start by ArcticVulpix (Encanto (2021))
  8. Good Luck Hermit, She Makes Good Things Happen by Radia_Alstroemeria (Encanto (2021))
  9. Power Shuffle Playlist by AtarahDerekh (Encanto (2021))
  10. hush now sister, that's not what we think by vstormbaine (Encanto (2021))
  11. Doll On The Music Box by Mirabelharem (Encanto (2021))
  12. A Chance to Change, Grow, and Love by Catlovingmermaid (Encanto (2021))
  13. Casita Knows. So Casita Helps. (Discontinued) by DizzyRose (Encanto (2021))
  14. Extended Family is Still Family by ArcticVulpix (Encanto (2021))
  15. Can I Keep Him? by HotPatooty (Encanto (2021), How to Train Your Dragon (Movies))
  16. Encanto x Coco: Forgive but never forget by BBHONG (Encanto (2021), Coco (2017), more)
  17. Candle in the Night by bobalover21 (Encanto (2021))
  18. Eyes? I no longer need. by A_UncommonOccurrance (Encanto (2021))
  19. Second Chances by Jugare (Encanto (2021))
  20. The Two Seers by MoonCaterpillar (Encanto (2021))