Fics like Is it Casual Now?

Every time, Gemma swears it will be the last. She tells herself she won’t let Skye in again. Not into her bed, not into her heart. The emptiness that follows after Skye leaves is too much. But now, with Skye draped across her lap, her head nestled against Gemma’s thigh, all those promises slip away.

You may also like

1. Make me forget by sailorjules26 (Smile (Movies - Finn), Obsession (Movie 2025))
2. Little nightmares: Grin by Gabriel_From_TMC_REAL (Smile (Movies - Finn), Little Nightmares (Video Games))
3. Blood Keeps Them Warm by TheonetrueDuckman (Smile (Movies - Finn), Longlegs (Movie 2024), more)
4. The words that were taken from her... by YuiUltima (Obsession (Movie 2025), Smile (Movies - Finn))
5. The Skye Is Blue by SmileFanFiction (Smile (Movies - Finn))
6. Misery Loves Her Company (Smile (Movies - Finn))
7. ghosts that we knew by AzureInk (Smile (Movies - Finn))
8. There is no end to this Madness, lets go Mad Together by ic3storm (Smile (Movies - Finn))
9. Death Of Me by ErraticScissors (KPop Demon Hunters (2025), Smile (Movies - Finn))
10. And all it took...was one wish. by YuiUltima (Obsession (Movie 2025), Smile (Movies - Finn))
11. sometimes i think you might hate me, sometimes i think i might hate you by pocketsofposies (Smile (Movies - Finn), The Substance (2024))
12. metamorphosis by theheartlines (Smile (Movies - Finn))
13. I am not human by Gabriel_From_TMC_REAL (Smile (Movies - Finn))
14. Jagged Edges by xonceinadream (Smile (Movies - Finn))
15. Horrorverse by Blayno (Halloween (Movies 1978-2002), Alien Series, more)
16. I Made A Commitment by TwoKidsInATrenchCoat (Smile (Movies - Finn))
17. Death of Me by phil0sapphic (Smile (Movies - Finn))
18. The worst 6 days of Joel’s life by Sugar__Cubee (Smile (Movies - Finn))
19. ice cream truck by milzifier (Smile (Movies - Finn), Terrifier (Movies - Leone))
20. My Everything by HareKrishna (Smile (Movies - Finn))