Fics like It's a mystery (that I would pick you 10 out of 9 times)

Tex: Can you overshare something to make this less embarrassing? Firehose : Absolutely. I’m telling people I downloaded this app to get over my ex but really I realized I have feelings for my straight best friend Or, Eddie downloads a gay dating app and hits it off with a suspiciously familiar mystery man (it's Buck).

You may also like

  1. Gay Parent Support Group by K15n (9-1-1 (TV))
  2. if you say it with your hands by hammersmiths (9-1-1 (TV))
  3. a leaf falls on loneliness by iimpossible_things (9-1-1 (TV))
  4. Carnations by whileyouresleeping (9-1-1 (TV))
  5. shout if you want my heart by hattalove (9-1-1 (TV))
  6. plot twist (and turns) by autumnchills (9-1-1 (TV))
  7. and we can stay all day by trippedandfell (9-1-1 (TV))
  8. the lion does not concern himself with the opinion of a pennsylvanian by beetlesandstars (9-1-1 (TV))
  9. you’ve got to live a life you would die for by fleetinghearts (9-1-1 (TV))
  10. baby, come home by coupe_de_foudre (9-1-1 (TV))
  11. everything's coming up milhouse by hammersmiths (9-1-1 (TV))
  12. 118 Hwaiting! by orphan_account (9-1-1 (TV))
  13. maybe i’ll be brave enough by then by trippedandfell (9-1-1 (TV))
  14. Stick With You by soft_satan (9-1-1 (TV))
  15. With a Friend in the Dark by orphan_account (9-1-1 (TV))
  16. In Vino Veritas by eightpackdiaz (9-1-1 (TV))
  17. I Do (I Really, Really Do) by eightpackdiaz (9-1-1 (TV))
  18. tell the whole wide world and this room by hattalove (9-1-1 (TV))
  19. call your girlfriend by bleakmonday (9-1-1 (TV))
  20. baby, you were my picket fence by spaceprincessem (9-1-1 (TV))