Fics like Hiram's Harem

Archie and Reggie get into legal trouble while pledging a frat, leading to their shared naked humiliation. Thankfully Hiram is there to bail them out. But does the handsome daddy have another agenda? Trigger warning because anti-gay slurs are used throughout. There's a lot of confused heterosexual angst in this fic.

You may also like

1. say hey (i love you) by Jenny_Jensen (Riverdale (TV 2017))
2. for all i know of you now by cherylbombshells (Riverdale (TV 2017))
3. Shameless: A Normal Gallagher...Kind of by Choejhulkp9 (Shameless (US), Euphoria (TV 2019), more)
4. The Campaign Manager by JanoMnoMno (Riverdale (TV 2017))
5. Skin Tight by dirtymalecelebs (American (US) Actor RPF, Canadian Music RPF, more)
6. Simply Complicated by Null123 (Riverdale (TV 2017), Archie Comics)
7. fear is the most elegant weapon, your hands are never messy by kjapa (Riverdale (TV 2017))
8. Quite a Ride by dirtymalecelebs (Riverdale (TV 2017), Teen Wolf (TV), more)
9. Incest is fun by JerryHale (The Gifted (Marvel TV 2017), Chucky (TV 2021), more)
10. Let Me Love the Lonely by PeaceBlessingsPeyton (Riverdale (TV 2017))
11. The Quest Reward by zxandris (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Fate: The Winx Saga (TV), more)
12. Southside High by noorakardemmomesaetre (Riverdale (TV 2017))
13. Spidey Does Riverdale by orphan_account (Spider-Man (Comicverse), Riverdale (TV 2017))
14. Way down we go by Yukichouji (Riverdale (TV 2017), Archie Comics & Related Fandoms)
15. One Shot Requests (Currently Open) by aft33 (Glee, 13 Reasons Why (TV), more)
16. Tempting Fate by KaylaRann (Riverdale (TV 2017))
17. The Shining Forest by delightseeker (Riverdale (TV 2017))
18. The Lady's Honor by jjonesin4 (Riverdale (TV 2017), Archie Comics & Related Fandoms, more)
19. Tacos and Tequila by jugandbettsdetectiveagency (Riverdale (TV 2017))
20. Long Reach Collection by Dragonnfire (Riverdale (TV 2017))