Fics like We've waited long enough - Billy Loomis x reader x Stu Macher

Y/N's had a crush on Billy and Stu since she was little, she can't deny it. However, through the years it was made clear to her that no matter how much they flirt with her, she would never be their final pick. They have girlfriends, afterall, what chance does she have? Thus canon events mixed with a little silliness insue :D

You may also like

  1. False Scare by GoWithTheFlo20 (Scream (Movies), Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling)
  2. Who's Sorry Now by BatCatMooney63 (Stranger Things (TV 2016), Scream (Movies))
  3. ꜱᴜʙᴛᴇʀꜰᴜɢᴇ ⌞ ˢˡᵃˢʰᵉʳˢ ˣ ʳᵉᵃᵈᵉʳ ⌝ by Limie (The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (Movies), Scream (Movies), more)
  4. The Placebo Effect by KikuchiKun (Halloween Movies - All Media Types, Scream (Movies), more)
  5. class president and his first lady by MattUlrichSkeetLillard (Scream (Movies), Scream'd: An Unauthorized Musical Parody - Heard & Grayson)
  6. Dark Fic's by Ashley_Winchester_77 (The Avengers (Marvel Movies), Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, more)
  7. Final Cut by GoWithTheFlo20 (Scream (Movies), Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling)
  8. Hades by NeckingMyself (Scream (Movies), Scream (TV))
  9. You Gotta Be There For The Sequel by OceanicJessie (Scream (Movies), Scream (1996), more)
  10. when you scream, it drives me nuts (if you hang up, i'll spill your guts) by orphan_account (Scream (Movies))
  11. the victim | billy loomis x reader x stu macher by eulogysingr (Scream (Movies))
  12. Slasher Headcanons by gvtted_ratz (Friday the 13th Series (Movies), The Collector Series (Movies), more)
  13. Horror Slashers NSFW Alphabet by MadBoffin (Friday the 13th Series (Movies), Halloween Movies - All Media Types, more)
  14. Red Licorice by V_Era_18 (Scream (Movies))
  15. The Motive by Pink_October_Bones (Scream (Movies))
  16. Surviving the Game by Blot_Squisher (Dead by Daylight (Video Game), Scream (Movies), more)
  17. Mad about You by NeverGlooby, SpookyWandolier (Scream (Movies))
  18. We’ll All Be Laughing With You When You Die! by whats_those (Scream (Movies))
  19. EbonySlasher Reaction Collection by Ebonyslash (Halloween Movies - All Media Types, Friday the 13th Series (Movies), more)
  20. Debaser by Sharpthing (Scream (Movies), scream - Fandom)