Fics like Tell Me I'm Pretty

Gabriel decides to order pizza for him and his brother one night. He has an app on his phone and after he orders the food he sees there are directions he can write in for the delivery driver. Really, he does it as a gag. He asks the delivery guy to tell him a joke. The guy actually comes through. The guy also turns out to be one of his senior year students at the university, a good looking guy by the name of Dean. He decides he not only likes the pizza, but he likes Dean's friendliness outside of the classroom. It becomes a running joke to order on nights Dean is working just to put silly requests down in the instructions box. Until one night he is stuck in the bathroom and leaves his brother Cas to answer the door. Gabe had added a request that night. Tell me I'm pretty As always, Dean follows through with the instructions. Too bad no one let Cas in on the joke.

You may also like

  1. A Single Kiss by whelvenwings (Supernatural)
  2. Something Unexpected by justanothersong (Supernatural)
  3. from first until forever by teacass (Supernatural)
  4. A Special Something by whelvenwings (Supernatural)
  5. La Vie A Plus by K_K_TiBal (Supernatural)
  6. Summer Session by justanothersong (Supernatural)
  7. The Honey Bee Theories by queentangerine (Supernatural)
  8. When Cas Was There by manofbeskar (Supernatural)
  9. Love in a McHopeless Place by Weasleychick32 (Supernatural)
  10. Too Adorable To Resist by lemonsorbae (Supernatural)
  11. Ergative/Absolutive by glassedplanets (Supernatural)
  12. Shorten the Distance by GhostGarrison (Supernatural)
  13. Do You Understand What You Do to Me? by anonymous_dragon (Supernatural)
  14. Of Evil Friends and Party Games by ratherbehere (Supernatural)
  15. Detailed by exalteddean (Supernatural)
  16. The One Where Dean Gets Drugged by HolyFuckingHell (Supernatural)
  17. Rumor Has It by GatesKeeper (Supernatural)
  18. grip them tight and raise them from pernicion by Flux (Supernatural)
  19. A Little Guidance by orphan_account (Supernatural)
  20. Your Call Cannot Be Completed As Dialed by K_K_TiBal, eBob (Supernatural)