Fics like Unusually Pleasant Conversations

Hey all! Thanks for being here and reading! This series of one-shots focuses on the conversations between Matthew and Mary Magdalene that happened off-screen. I know many see a romance there, and I can't deny it either—especially with Matthew's actor confirming his character's crush on Mary in The Chosen’s After show. And of course, he called Mary unusually pleasant to look at and defended her when John yelled at her. I'm not sure how many chapters this will be, but I have lots of ideas and can't wait to write for Season 5! Please comment with your thoughts, requests, or advice. If there's an episode or scene you wanted more "Matthew and Mary" in, let me know in the comments, and I'll create a chapter for it!

You may also like

  1. The Parable of the Lost Brother by Deedlejuice (The Chosen (TV 2017))
  2. (My Fingers are) Outta Place by Deedlejuice (The Chosen (TV 2017))
  3. A Band of Apostles, a Rabbi, and a Storm Girl by Brokenfangirl22 (The Chosen (TV 2017), Christian Bible (New Testament))
  4. The Boiling Isles react to the human kingdom and the beings that inhabit that world. by ShadowKing1127 (The Owl House (Cartoon), DCU, more)
  5. The Days In-between by Just_A_Fangirl22 (The Chosen (TV 2017))
  6. I’m Just a Kid (Thanks for Letting Me Be One) by Deedlejuice (The Chosen (TV 2017))
  7. my prayer has always been love by ghostsmp3 (Christian Bible (New Testament), The Chosen (TV 2017))
  8. Psalm 23: Anxiety by Just_A_Fangirl22 (The Chosen (TV 2017))
  9. Principium by Jbart447 (The Chosen (TV 2017), Christian Bible (New Testament))
  10. Trouble by Just_A_Fangirl22 (The Chosen (TV 2017))
  11. Save My Lambs by Aslans_Princess (The Chosen (TV 2017))
  12. Gentile. by The_Chosen_Fanfiction (The Chosen (TV 2017))
  13. God's (non-existing) Mistake by the-chosen-afficionata (The Chosen (TV 2017))
  14. Tabled discussions by orphan_account (The Chosen (TV 2017))
  15. And He a Pharisee by Aslans_Princess (The Chosen (TV 2017))
  16. Paired by Purpler (The Chosen (TV 2017))
  17. Crumbs & Consequences by Just_A_Fangirl22 (The Chosen (TV 2017))
  18. Everyone Loves Matthew by Deedlejuice (The Chosen (TV 2017))
  19. Heart Lost. by AnzieLove (תנ"ך | Tanakh, Christian Bible (Old Testament), more)
  20. The Chosen: Stories Untold by Just_A_Fangirl22 (The Chosen (TV 2017))