Fics like Signed, Your Penpal

Geno and Nightmare fall in love through anonymous notes to each other and their love of books. But of course, Geno doesn’t stay Geno forever and Nightmare doesn’t handle it well.

You may also like

  1. Real Gone by JayBird421 (Undertale (Video Game))
  2. Tree of Destruction by Makis_Stories (Undertale (Video Game))
  3. For Better or For Worse (An “If Blue joined the Bad Sanses Story”) by ViridescentLotus (Undertale (Video Game))
  4. KFC becomes siblings by Laminated_paper_chain (Deltarune (Video Game), Undertale (Video Game))
  5. Dewdrops (Undertale (Video Game))
  6. Lost Together in a Sea of Stars by Hellsaint7w7 (Undertale (Video Game))
  7. Nocturne Harbour by Hellsaint7w7 (Undertale (Video Game))
  8. The Tree of Feelings: New Branches & Balled Roots by yastaghr (Undertale (Video Game))
  9. Tsunatale by Novirp13 (Katekyou Hitman Reborn!, Undertale (Video Game))
  10. Mismatched Vagabonds (But Find Home In Each Other) [On Hiatus!] by mizu_pizuuuu (Undertale AU - Fandom, Undertale (Video Game))
  11. Blind Sided by ConstantlyConfused250 (Undertale (Video Game))
  12. Bonus Content by SpectrumWriting (Undertale (Video Game), Deltarune (Video Game))
  13. He Left and Now He’s Safe by Person281 (Undertale (Video Game))
  14. What do i do with a love that won't sit still? by InkyOverlord (Undertale (Video Game))
  15. MorTificaTion by SoftUmbrella (Undertale (Video Game))
  16. heal me by charamelwrites (Undertale (Video Game))
  17. be sensitive like you by perplexed_inkstain (Undertale (Video Game))
  18. Diary of a Temporal King (Undertale (Video Game))
  19. Tether the Soul, Reborn again by EiraAderyn (Undertale (Video Game))
  20. That Was Fine. by -%20%20Scrap%20-%20Paper%20- (Undertale (Video Game))